A monumental piece, Helen! I've been reading you for well nigh ten years, and this article and this article can serve as both an introduction to and summary of your work to date. (Not that I want you to stop here. Please keep writing!)
Since the ascendancy of Trump, I've been examining the idea of "consent of the governed, for here in the USA the vast majority of us governed, comprising those who voted for Trump and those who didn't vote at all, consented to being governed by a strongman cum plutocrats. Those of us in the liberal minority did not consent to this government. In this way, it appears democracy has deconstructed itself. The challenge for us liberals in the USA is not just promoting liberalism but first restoring democracy, this time with robust safeguards against authoritarianism.
Whenever such a claim is made I have become accustomed to assuming the application of a highly inaccurate, proprietary definition of the -ism in question. Postliberal thinkers have made a habit of obfuscating their equivocation as they frivolously dance between various left of centre phenomenons. Hardly ever so they actually strike the actual content of liberalism. Perhaps they achieve high accuracy when they criticise open borders in europe, which at least has a economically liberal motivation under the four freedoms. But most of the time they conflate particularist identitarianism with liberalism itself, which is ironic since its main appeal is universality
This essay is powerful pushback against the frivolous and often politically motivated way "liberalism" is used in much contemporary discourse. With my editor cap on, I imagine it constituting the core of a book's Part 2, In Which the Author Vanquishes Misunderstandings, Misreadings, and Malign Misappropriations of Liberalism.
This is something that Thomas Prosser and I specifically discuss in our book, Beyond Woke and Anti-woke. There is something incoherent about the idea of hyperliberalism. If, driven to extremes, certain liberal tenets begin to seem positively illiberal in their applications, what’s the point of describing them as being still in some way liberal? They have crossed a certain rubicon. They are illiberal.
To me, the more interesting parallels are with religious fundamentalism.
Helen, this piece does the vital work of separating the objective 'Signal' of civic mechanics from the subjective, low-friction 'Story' of populist labeling.
I work with the Center for Self and Civic Rationality Project, we track exactly this kind of structural failure. When political tribes use highly charged, imprecise terms like 'extremist' or 'hyper-liberal' to score points, they are actively avoiding the high-friction work of rigorous debate. You highlight how this conflation destroys the shared language necessary for a functional public sphere.
When we replace precise, structural definitions with tribal grievance, we lose the ability to hold our own allies accountable. Thank you for cutting through the noise and defending the structural integrity of these concepts.
Liberal = progressive in America. Matt is pretending to be a yank. If he was pretending to be an Australian he wouldn't making that mistake, where liberal = conservative.
But despite you negate it, I do think that at the root of the confusion, what allows the confusion, is, in large part, something that has to do with the split meaning of the world "liberal" on the two sides of the Atlantic, which has been entrenched by the hegemony of American culture over the West.
The split is not irrelevant: it has always defined two distinct visions of the political world.
On this side of the ocean, it is Gladstone and his ilk: the Classical Liberalism. Liberalism is not Progressivism -- we have the socialist umbrella parties for that. Nor it is Conservatism -- we have the conservative umbrella parties for that. Liberalism is about a few, very clear principles without which a functioning democratic society of free individuals cannot subsist -- you have beautifully listed them all. And this is why there can be conservative liberals and progressive liberals, and most liberals will be conservative in some respect and progressive in some other respect, granted the keeping fixed of those few but essential liberal tenets.
If you wish, this is very well evidenced in Clegg's party, and likely one of the reasons of its overall ineffectiveness in the present age.
On the other side of the ocean, the lack of any proper socialist party has driven the conflation of liberal concepts with progressivism, in a political milieu that, not to quote G.B. Shaw (but always tempted to), has never been truly inclined to moderation or reason, and where the "conservatives" in general always suffered severely from an obscurantist penchant on most social issues, and were burdened by the resentment of the slavery question. Classical Liberals in this milieu have had more difficulty identifying themselves as such, splitting between assuming a moderate progressive stance and embracing an exclusively economic maximalist liberalism.
The latter vision of liberalism seems to me to have become culturally dominant also in Europe, creating a growing confusion, to the point that we have needed, in the face of the rise of the illiberal left that yet still in large part claimed to uphold at least a number of liberal principles, to get to calls to muster, and to state aloud again and anew the old principles of Classical Liberalism.
To this confusion has been added another factor, which is what I believe muddles Syed's discourse: the capture of liberal institutions by increasingly radical sectors of progressive thought.
Most radical progressive theories start from a base of reasonable liberal aspirations and move the goalposts farther and farther on idealistic grounds ever further disjoined from reality. Let us not here speak about the socio-psychological motivations of the success of these theories in certain sectors of society. But just looking at the facts on one single issue:
The bloating of Human Rights and related enforcement, where protection of individuals and groups from discrimination based on a number of characteristics becomes a system of judgement and repression/grants based on an ever-increasing list of possible offences and harms more and more selected on the basis of political ideology. The discourse over racism and sexism has gone the same way.
And this process has happened in the UN, in a vast number of NGOs, in our governments, where a whole set of rules and attitudes have been pushed (in part unconsciously) to extremes and interpretations that have no place in liberalism and are disastrous for liberalism, while encouraging the engagement of every kind of bad actors.
But people like Syed see the liberal roots of the things that have shifted and are not capable of seeing the break, so they call a degeneration (influenced by many originally illiberal theories) hyper-liberalism. Which is not in any way. You may call free speech absolutism a form of hyper-liberalism -- certainly not the "woke" cult, or its fixation with purity.
It is the same mistake that many make confusing Social Democracy, or even theoretical Socialism, with Communism.
Ideas often are nested into one another. The inability to see where they break off and become a different thing is a terrible blindness.
It is like to say that Marx is hyper-Hengel. Or, to go in darker places, that Hitler is hyper-DeMaistre. (And no, friends on the Left, I am in no way comparing Marx to Hitler, just sets of roots from which completely different plants were born. In biology it is called speciation, and nobody serious can say that a horse and a eohippus are the same).
This for Syed. Goodwin, I am afraid, has no intellectual honesty to be spoken of.
What if the problems people have with current elites are on a different axis than liberalism or populism?
People like Merkel, et al. strike me more as "globalist" in the sense of seeing no difference between her own voters and people elsewhere, of de-emphasizing patriotism in favor of a global citizenry concept, and of ceding national sovereignty to international law and its bodies. This provokes a nationalist response ("nationalism" in this case being support for patriotism, national self-determination, and the belief one's nation is legitimate without appeal to international norms). Insomuch as liberalism developed with the concept of the Westhphalian nation-state, it too can object to globalism.
"Technocratic" too, in the sense that they see the people of their country as things to be managed because they do not know their own best interest. This can certainly provoke a populist response (especially against "experts"), but liberalism can absolutely find fault with technocracy as well.
Thank you for writing this. I popped my head up from my daily concerns and was fortunate to find it.
In particular, thank you for introducing me to Mike Burke's "The Liberalism We Live and Breathe" (https://www.queermajority.com/essays-all/the-liberalism-we-live-and-breathe). I grew up in a deeply homophobic time and place, and his essay describes a change I have undergone myself. It was a powerful reminder that a Burkean conservative like me, one who thinks things are the best they've ever been, can also be a liberal in the sense you are reclaiming.
Thank you both for the recommendation and praise of my work, should either of you be interested in how I develop these themes in order to address the explicitly anti-liberal right and the thinkers behind it, then I should like to draw your attention to my latest article for New Discourses—Liberty Made Ordinary: The Inheritance Post-Liberalism Cannot See
Although Matthew Syed’s use of the term ‘hyperliberal’ probably does muddy his argument somewhat, I nevertheless think it should be noted that in paragraph three of his Times article (https://www.thetimes.com/comment/columnists/article/angela-merkel-populist-extreme-right-2mxspz6c0), he proposes defining extremism as ‘acting out of proportion with context, history or consent’ and argues persuasively that Angela Merkel’s actions in 2015 - ‘opening the door to almost a million unvetted, largely male asylum seekers’ from outside Europe without due regard for voters' wishes or the ruinous financial and social fabric costs that are still being incurred far beyond Germany – fit that definition pretty well.
That doesn’t help much either. You’d still need to argue for why the context, history and consent should be deferred to. The American Revolution defied all three. Protestors of hijab in Iran are called extremists by the regime because what they are not doing is not in accordance with an Islamic context, history and consent. I’d support both because they are trying to establish a new context based on liberty. People arguing against Merkel’s policies will have to argue that her decisions were bad, caused harm, denied freedom, were opposed to the wishes of the people who elected her etc.
Plenty of people, including Syed and Goodwin, are, indeed, now arguing that Merkel’s policies were bad, caused harm, denied freedom, were opposed to the wishes of the people who elected her etc. My point was that Syed at least defined his use of the term ‘extremism’ within the context of his article, admittedly better than he defined his use of the term ‘hyperliberal’’.
In my experience in the past of being involved in socialist/anarchist movements and now in “far-right” nationalist ones, the situation is worse than you suggest. The left has long adopted a Rousseau-esque disinterest in history and philosophy. They completely ignore the Enlightenment and instead focus on a blunt critique of contemporary society. The right engages with liberal philosophers directly (as opposed to the article you cited which only mentions them abstractly), but they either completely misread or intentionally misrepresent their liberal opponents.
But sprinkled throughout this article, is another common misrepresentation of liberalism - that it is a “view from nowhere”, or ideologically neutral. The same arguments Quine made to dismantle logical positivism can apply here - liberalism has metaphysical assumptions and where these conflict with other ideologies, the disagreements cannot be rationally adjudicated. This leads to certain political conclusions, and I would guess the article that you dealt with here would have been better off making an argument along these lines.
I’m not sure where it seems I presented the situation as not bad? I have spent the last decade arguing that it is bad and focusing on it almost singlemindedly full-time. What would be evidence that I realise the seriousness of the problem on the left? You can Google me if you’ve not come across my work on the subject.
I don’t know what it means for liberalism to be ideologically neutral. It’s an ideology. I’m arguing that it’s a good one.
I have not been following the Syed and Goodwin discussions so the main benefits I drew from this were the 'core liberal principles' and your personal statement (beginning "I am politically…") - with which I agree.
With regard to the disagreement between groups, I think you assume too much with "how", "which", and "how". I would prefer as a starting point: "...'whether' borders should be secured, 'whether' energy policies should take into account relevant factors and 'whether' governments should best represent the interests of their citizens."
Which brings me to the principles - which I found very helpful - and to which I'd like to propose an addition that has the force of necessity – provided that one is truth seeking:
In assessing a situation or deciding a course of action, all relevant issues and explanation should be taken into account – that is, matters should not be excluded on ideological grounds. [Paraphrased from ET Jaynes "Probability Theory"].
A monumental piece, Helen! I've been reading you for well nigh ten years, and this article and this article can serve as both an introduction to and summary of your work to date. (Not that I want you to stop here. Please keep writing!)
Since the ascendancy of Trump, I've been examining the idea of "consent of the governed, for here in the USA the vast majority of us governed, comprising those who voted for Trump and those who didn't vote at all, consented to being governed by a strongman cum plutocrats. Those of us in the liberal minority did not consent to this government. In this way, it appears democracy has deconstructed itself. The challenge for us liberals in the USA is not just promoting liberalism but first restoring democracy, this time with robust safeguards against authoritarianism.
Whenever such a claim is made I have become accustomed to assuming the application of a highly inaccurate, proprietary definition of the -ism in question. Postliberal thinkers have made a habit of obfuscating their equivocation as they frivolously dance between various left of centre phenomenons. Hardly ever so they actually strike the actual content of liberalism. Perhaps they achieve high accuracy when they criticise open borders in europe, which at least has a economically liberal motivation under the four freedoms. But most of the time they conflate particularist identitarianism with liberalism itself, which is ironic since its main appeal is universality
This essay is powerful pushback against the frivolous and often politically motivated way "liberalism" is used in much contemporary discourse. With my editor cap on, I imagine it constituting the core of a book's Part 2, In Which the Author Vanquishes Misunderstandings, Misreadings, and Malign Misappropriations of Liberalism.
'extremism in defense of liberty is no vice' Barry Goldwater
'moderation in the pursuit of justice is no virtue' also, Barry Goldwater
This is something that Thomas Prosser and I specifically discuss in our book, Beyond Woke and Anti-woke. There is something incoherent about the idea of hyperliberalism. If, driven to extremes, certain liberal tenets begin to seem positively illiberal in their applications, what’s the point of describing them as being still in some way liberal? They have crossed a certain rubicon. They are illiberal.
To me, the more interesting parallels are with religious fundamentalism.
Helen, this piece does the vital work of separating the objective 'Signal' of civic mechanics from the subjective, low-friction 'Story' of populist labeling.
I work with the Center for Self and Civic Rationality Project, we track exactly this kind of structural failure. When political tribes use highly charged, imprecise terms like 'extremist' or 'hyper-liberal' to score points, they are actively avoiding the high-friction work of rigorous debate. You highlight how this conflation destroys the shared language necessary for a functional public sphere.
When we replace precise, structural definitions with tribal grievance, we lose the ability to hold our own allies accountable. Thank you for cutting through the noise and defending the structural integrity of these concepts.
- Daniel J Cogan
Liberal = progressive in America. Matt is pretending to be a yank. If he was pretending to be an Australian he wouldn't making that mistake, where liberal = conservative.
Loved this, thanks!
Excellent, excellent and exhaustive article.
But despite you negate it, I do think that at the root of the confusion, what allows the confusion, is, in large part, something that has to do with the split meaning of the world "liberal" on the two sides of the Atlantic, which has been entrenched by the hegemony of American culture over the West.
The split is not irrelevant: it has always defined two distinct visions of the political world.
On this side of the ocean, it is Gladstone and his ilk: the Classical Liberalism. Liberalism is not Progressivism -- we have the socialist umbrella parties for that. Nor it is Conservatism -- we have the conservative umbrella parties for that. Liberalism is about a few, very clear principles without which a functioning democratic society of free individuals cannot subsist -- you have beautifully listed them all. And this is why there can be conservative liberals and progressive liberals, and most liberals will be conservative in some respect and progressive in some other respect, granted the keeping fixed of those few but essential liberal tenets.
If you wish, this is very well evidenced in Clegg's party, and likely one of the reasons of its overall ineffectiveness in the present age.
On the other side of the ocean, the lack of any proper socialist party has driven the conflation of liberal concepts with progressivism, in a political milieu that, not to quote G.B. Shaw (but always tempted to), has never been truly inclined to moderation or reason, and where the "conservatives" in general always suffered severely from an obscurantist penchant on most social issues, and were burdened by the resentment of the slavery question. Classical Liberals in this milieu have had more difficulty identifying themselves as such, splitting between assuming a moderate progressive stance and embracing an exclusively economic maximalist liberalism.
The latter vision of liberalism seems to me to have become culturally dominant also in Europe, creating a growing confusion, to the point that we have needed, in the face of the rise of the illiberal left that yet still in large part claimed to uphold at least a number of liberal principles, to get to calls to muster, and to state aloud again and anew the old principles of Classical Liberalism.
To this confusion has been added another factor, which is what I believe muddles Syed's discourse: the capture of liberal institutions by increasingly radical sectors of progressive thought.
Most radical progressive theories start from a base of reasonable liberal aspirations and move the goalposts farther and farther on idealistic grounds ever further disjoined from reality. Let us not here speak about the socio-psychological motivations of the success of these theories in certain sectors of society. But just looking at the facts on one single issue:
The bloating of Human Rights and related enforcement, where protection of individuals and groups from discrimination based on a number of characteristics becomes a system of judgement and repression/grants based on an ever-increasing list of possible offences and harms more and more selected on the basis of political ideology. The discourse over racism and sexism has gone the same way.
And this process has happened in the UN, in a vast number of NGOs, in our governments, where a whole set of rules and attitudes have been pushed (in part unconsciously) to extremes and interpretations that have no place in liberalism and are disastrous for liberalism, while encouraging the engagement of every kind of bad actors.
But people like Syed see the liberal roots of the things that have shifted and are not capable of seeing the break, so they call a degeneration (influenced by many originally illiberal theories) hyper-liberalism. Which is not in any way. You may call free speech absolutism a form of hyper-liberalism -- certainly not the "woke" cult, or its fixation with purity.
It is the same mistake that many make confusing Social Democracy, or even theoretical Socialism, with Communism.
Ideas often are nested into one another. The inability to see where they break off and become a different thing is a terrible blindness.
It is like to say that Marx is hyper-Hengel. Or, to go in darker places, that Hitler is hyper-DeMaistre. (And no, friends on the Left, I am in no way comparing Marx to Hitler, just sets of roots from which completely different plants were born. In biology it is called speciation, and nobody serious can say that a horse and a eohippus are the same).
This for Syed. Goodwin, I am afraid, has no intellectual honesty to be spoken of.
What if the problems people have with current elites are on a different axis than liberalism or populism?
People like Merkel, et al. strike me more as "globalist" in the sense of seeing no difference between her own voters and people elsewhere, of de-emphasizing patriotism in favor of a global citizenry concept, and of ceding national sovereignty to international law and its bodies. This provokes a nationalist response ("nationalism" in this case being support for patriotism, national self-determination, and the belief one's nation is legitimate without appeal to international norms). Insomuch as liberalism developed with the concept of the Westhphalian nation-state, it too can object to globalism.
"Technocratic" too, in the sense that they see the people of their country as things to be managed because they do not know their own best interest. This can certainly provoke a populist response (especially against "experts"), but liberalism can absolutely find fault with technocracy as well.
Thank you for writing this. I popped my head up from my daily concerns and was fortunate to find it.
In particular, thank you for introducing me to Mike Burke's "The Liberalism We Live and Breathe" (https://www.queermajority.com/essays-all/the-liberalism-we-live-and-breathe). I grew up in a deeply homophobic time and place, and his essay describes a change I have undergone myself. It was a powerful reminder that a Burkean conservative like me, one who thinks things are the best they've ever been, can also be a liberal in the sense you are reclaiming.
Absolutely! @Mike Burke
Thank you both for the recommendation and praise of my work, should either of you be interested in how I develop these themes in order to address the explicitly anti-liberal right and the thinkers behind it, then I should like to draw your attention to my latest article for New Discourses—Liberty Made Ordinary: The Inheritance Post-Liberalism Cannot See
https://newdiscourses.com/2026/09/liberty-inheritance-post-liberalism/
Although Matthew Syed’s use of the term ‘hyperliberal’ probably does muddy his argument somewhat, I nevertheless think it should be noted that in paragraph three of his Times article (https://www.thetimes.com/comment/columnists/article/angela-merkel-populist-extreme-right-2mxspz6c0), he proposes defining extremism as ‘acting out of proportion with context, history or consent’ and argues persuasively that Angela Merkel’s actions in 2015 - ‘opening the door to almost a million unvetted, largely male asylum seekers’ from outside Europe without due regard for voters' wishes or the ruinous financial and social fabric costs that are still being incurred far beyond Germany – fit that definition pretty well.
That doesn’t help much either. You’d still need to argue for why the context, history and consent should be deferred to. The American Revolution defied all three. Protestors of hijab in Iran are called extremists by the regime because what they are not doing is not in accordance with an Islamic context, history and consent. I’d support both because they are trying to establish a new context based on liberty. People arguing against Merkel’s policies will have to argue that her decisions were bad, caused harm, denied freedom, were opposed to the wishes of the people who elected her etc.
Plenty of people, including Syed and Goodwin, are, indeed, now arguing that Merkel’s policies were bad, caused harm, denied freedom, were opposed to the wishes of the people who elected her etc. My point was that Syed at least defined his use of the term ‘extremism’ within the context of his article, admittedly better than he defined his use of the term ‘hyperliberal’’.
Yes, I am just disagreeing with this understanding of extreme
In my experience in the past of being involved in socialist/anarchist movements and now in “far-right” nationalist ones, the situation is worse than you suggest. The left has long adopted a Rousseau-esque disinterest in history and philosophy. They completely ignore the Enlightenment and instead focus on a blunt critique of contemporary society. The right engages with liberal philosophers directly (as opposed to the article you cited which only mentions them abstractly), but they either completely misread or intentionally misrepresent their liberal opponents.
But sprinkled throughout this article, is another common misrepresentation of liberalism - that it is a “view from nowhere”, or ideologically neutral. The same arguments Quine made to dismantle logical positivism can apply here - liberalism has metaphysical assumptions and where these conflict with other ideologies, the disagreements cannot be rationally adjudicated. This leads to certain political conclusions, and I would guess the article that you dealt with here would have been better off making an argument along these lines.
I’m not sure where it seems I presented the situation as not bad? I have spent the last decade arguing that it is bad and focusing on it almost singlemindedly full-time. What would be evidence that I realise the seriousness of the problem on the left? You can Google me if you’ve not come across my work on the subject.
I don’t know what it means for liberalism to be ideologically neutral. It’s an ideology. I’m arguing that it’s a good one.
I have not been following the Syed and Goodwin discussions so the main benefits I drew from this were the 'core liberal principles' and your personal statement (beginning "I am politically…") - with which I agree.
With regard to the disagreement between groups, I think you assume too much with "how", "which", and "how". I would prefer as a starting point: "...'whether' borders should be secured, 'whether' energy policies should take into account relevant factors and 'whether' governments should best represent the interests of their citizens."
Which brings me to the principles - which I found very helpful - and to which I'd like to propose an addition that has the force of necessity – provided that one is truth seeking:
In assessing a situation or deciding a course of action, all relevant issues and explanation should be taken into account – that is, matters should not be excluded on ideological grounds. [Paraphrased from ET Jaynes "Probability Theory"].