Thank you, Helen. Unsurprisingly, I agree with you. At its best, feminism is simply a form of humanism, with "humanism" here meaning a belief in the fundamental ethical equality of all human beings at birth and in the individual as the primary locus of autonomy and dignity. The same is true of "anti-racism." These words and their associated movements were necessary because many self-declared "humanists" effectively excluded women and ethnic minorities from full membership in the human species.
Human nature is expansive. It contains multitudes. There are differences between men and women on the whole, some of them quite important. But there are also undeniable commonalities among human beings that allow for understanding, recognition, and goodwill across sexes, cultures, races/ethnicities, etc. At its best, feminism recognizes as much. And thank you for extending me a bit of this recognition and goodwill.
But you don't actually treat people equally in practice though. Easy example: in the west, both sexes have equal opportunity to get completely drunk and have sex, yet if two people of different sexes do that one will be deemed as having raped the other, even if they were both just as impaired in terms of their decision making capacity. If however the people are not of different sexes the act will not be deemed rape. This is clearly not treating either the sexes or straight and gay people equally. What you are in fact telling people is: you have the same opportunity/freedom to do something, but if you avail yourself of that freedom we will treat you differently based on sex and sexual orientation
No, I’m not telling them that at all. That is the type of feminism that I expressly decried in the final section of my original note, the one to which this article is responding. The type of feminism you describe is very real, but I do not support it. I condemn it. In fact, I explicitly condemned it. I was very clear about this. Please do not put words in my mouth.
I meant "you" as in your society - you westerners - not you individually, I guess I should have made that clear. There is a big divide between what liberal societies and pundits preach in the abstract and what people living in your countries experience, that was my point. The version of an ideology you support might be the nominal (and legitimately worthy) goal, but if the one you decry is what people actually encounter in the wild, well, that has consequences. What something might be like at it's best ends up mattering little to people who only get to see it at it's worst. Thanks for replying anyway.
That's fair. The point that I was making is that language should be used in such a way as to distinguish the best in this matter from the worst. I am trying to reclaim "feminism," which historically is a very respectable term, from its more extreme proponents, of which there are sadly many. And I think Helen was making a similar point. If we do not do this, we run the risk of conflating liberal, humanistic feminism with critical theoretical feminism. And this will lead to an increase in both misandry and misogyny.
Helen, i'm a fan, but I must say this post rubs me the wrong way.
Your take on liberal feminism seems premised on feminists' theoretical description of themselves rather than on an empirical assessment of what liberal feminism manifestly is. You write "in principle, it’s not fundamentally about women at all."
But then you write this:
"It is a recognition that women are individuals and people, and as such should have equal social and moral status and the same opportunities and freedoms as men."
I notice your language shift. You write first that liberal feminism is not about women at all fundamentally, but about both sexes. Yet you describe liberal feminism as concerned with women--not both sexes, but women--enjoying the benefits of equality. I think this tension in language tracks the tension between what liberal feminism theoretically is and what it manifestsly is.
Where are the liberal feminists clamoring to have women subjected to the selective service on the same terms as men? Where are the liberal feminists demanding that women receive the same heightened criminal sentences for crimes as men, including the death penalty? Where are the liberal feminists recognizing that a sexual double standard seems to apply in the university sexual misconduct context? Yes, liberal feminists sometimes address these issues, but usually only in a token way, as if they're doing the bare minimum in order to qualify as technically caring about men too.
You write:
"Nevertheless, in principle, [the liberal feminist] stance also protects men and should the need to defend them against such discrimination arise, explicitly advocates that. Men, therefore, can appreciate this principle and the framing of it to apply to both sexes."
"In principle," sure. And, in principle, "white pride" it's simply about pride in being white. It is not enough to tell me to celebrate liberal feminism because of the principles it abstractly claims to espouse. The proof is in the pudding and the pudding tastes like like less than genuine equality. Liberal feminism is relatively friendly to men compared to radical feminism, sure. i'm not saying that liberal feminists hate men. I am saying that they don't give two French farts about men, and therefore they don't deserve my admiration. Liberal feminism is and has always been gynocentric in practice. So why should I believe it's really something else? Because wikipedia says that they are about equality for both sexes?
In system theory there is a principle of progress where the course corrections early on eventually help achieve the purpose of the system, but then there is the inevitable corruption that occurs from human nature to constantly want more.
The design of Western democracy and the freedom to agitate for cause was always supposed to work this way:
People take time from their normal productive endeavors, including the crushing demands for managing a family and providing safety, security and sustenance, to agitate for a cause. Then after the war or the vote, people go back to their normal productive endeavors.
In this way, the "movement" if you will is always a temporary project that seeks to achieve some outcome and then ends.
Feminism has become an industry, and it has been corrupted as per the Shirky Principle. It in fact achieved all and more based on its initial outcome targets. It then should have gone away. But the feminists had attached themselves to the movement as a perpetual power, status and money-making enterprise. And feminized men attached themselves to the feminists for the same.
The movement went over the apogee of positive returns and has been on the downward slope for the last several decades. The 3rd and 4th wave feminists agenda is no longer about female choice and female equality. It is about pushing ideas that are the death of Western democratic capitalist liberal society to be replaced with a collectivist design that these feminists think will acquire them more power, status and money.
Feminism is frankly the current primary enemy of Western civilization. It is the new fascist movement and WWIII is upon us. Feminist females have become the conduit of destruction... the Pandora's Box fable come to life.
That's just feminism in an institutional sense. Any and all institutions end up moving in this direction. (But wow, an institution besides religion is being attacked!)
In the meantime it can't go away, because the biological differences between the sexes makes reversion to power inequality eternally tempting in human societies.
Keeping the main focus on the individual always much appreciated.
As I believe you have mentioned, anti-woke efforts are sometimes going too far these days. I am particularly sensitive to the generalizations about men and women I am hearing more and more often lately in liberal quarters. (Even "psychological differences" is going too far for me.) (Add particulars, and "generally" and I'm usually OK.)
I've heard that research shows some general differences between men and women's brains, which I am not knowledgeable enough to critique. Is it going too far into a 'post-modernist' mentality to say that my experience has shown me a lot of harm done to individuals who do not conform to some model of one sex or the other? To be a girl child who is considered odd for liking math. To be a boy child disapproved of for not being athletic.
Most of my life I have looked forward to a world which allows individuals to be their individual selves but with the left seeming to follow the right into lauding generalities over individuation, I sometimes wonder if we are fated to go in the other direction.
Liberalism is an excellent word at its root (liber = free), though over time it’s largely been co-opted to mean freedom PLUS a varying set of things that should be forced upon others in the service of personally compelling good intentions. Voluntaryism is a useful word in place of what liberalism once meant. Regardless of which meaning you tend towards, thanks for the thoughtful article (and the pointer to MJN Williams).
TLDR. Sorry Helen, but, offhand, feminism is something of a joke, a clownshow, all cohorts and sects -- over 20 at last count -- riding madly off in all directions -- as the English-Canadian humorist Stephen Leacock put it some 100 years ago.
You should have read the article because it criticizes radical feminism and other ultra-identitarian ideologies while arguing liberal feminism is a logical sub-focus of liberal activism as it reinforces individualism and moral universalism.
She isn't arguing one is the true sect over the others. She is arguing for a feminism rooted in individualism and equal rights over illiberal indentitarian sects. She criticized the 19 illiberal sects of feminism in her article.
Feminism consists of different groups of people. Pluckrose explains exactly which group she supports here, and it is a very coherent and principled stance. Perhaps you can explain how universal rights and individual freedom are "a joke, a clownshow"?
So she is championing one sect of over 20. Whole bunch of very questionable premises probably common to many of them, probably her own sect included, that weighs against them all. Failed ideology from square one. Cases in point being Koertge & Patai's Professing Feminism:
Patai and Koertge are classical liberal feminists that criticized radical, indentitarian feminism in their works. Helen's argument here is also the same.
Of course not. Why would you read the arguments in favour of one of the 38,000 Christian sects over any other one? Same difference -- various untenable articles of faith through the lot of them.
You might read those links of mine about the general criticisms of ALL of feminism -- bit of a joke from square one.
These are great points and I am definitely in general agreement! I think there is some need for recognition that some situations around reproduction may need a different legal framework than simple equality which is one thing that makes intermediate scrutiny jurisprudence (in the US context) pretty interesting. Setting aside Roe/abortion for the moment, first came Griswold on the pill. Do women have an articulable right to enjoy sex (which, contrary to some things I have heard on podcasts lately, we actually do?!) and still maintain control of their definitions about conceiving children? It’s a messy and vulnerable like of case law and one reason for feminism as a separate category (some other top of mind issues include the more clear cut cases of hostile work environment and sexual assault thought of course these can be articulated in a sex neutral way- but the fact intensive analysis may still need to take the sex identity of involved parties into account especially in working class settings.
I went on a side tangent after reading Duke law professor Doriane Coleman’s excellent book ‘On Sex and Gender’ a couple years back to refresh my memory on some of it and picked up a book on the 70s Ginsburg line of cases; recently purchased some Martha Nussbaum books on these topics. But those are some initial thoughts without having undertaken a deep review.
First: Helen, I have longed admired your fearless rationality and brilliant writing. While this essay is thoughtful, I disagree with it.
If legitimate feminism is liberalism—yet most feminists do not endorse the principles of liberalism—and feminism, as the data demonstrates, has achieved its original goals of equality before the law and of opportunity, I suggest we abandon the term. We can acknowledge its historic achievement, yet reject its modern corruption.
This is why I don’t call myself a feminist even though I suppprt the equal rights of women. I was asked to contribute a chapter to a book on feminisms and they cast me as a liberal post-feminist which sounds right to me.
But you don't actually treat people equally in practice though. Easy example: in the west, both sexes have equal opportunity to get completely drunk and have sex, yet if two people of different sexes do that one will be deemed as having raped the other, even if they were both just as impaired in terms of their decision making capacity. If however the people are not of different sexes the act will not be deemed rape. This is clearly not treating either the sexes or straight and gay people equally. What you are in fact telling people is: you have the same opportunity/freedom to do something, but if you avail yourself of that freedom we will treat you differently based on sex and sexual orientation
Yes, I don’t think anybody is arguing we already do treat people equally. Rather the argument is that the liberal individualist and universalist position hold that we should and failures to do so are what they oppose. If we were already treating people as individuals with the same rights and responsibilities, there’d be nothing to address here.
Thank you for the reply! I agree with having the same rights and responsibilities, I think they are a package deal and a lot of current year problems come from people wanting rights but not responsibilities, and full range of choices but not the full range of outcomes that may result from those choices. I think the equal responsibility part isn't sufficiently stressed at all in liberal discourse. Maybe because it would be less popular as an ideology if it did so?
Thank you for your response. I support women’s rights (beyond what has already been achieved) if we mean biological women deserve special accommodations because of distinct physical and psychological characteristics: excluding biological men from women’s sports, private spaces, and shelters; providing security for women in vulnerable places (e.g. dark parking lots); exclusion (possibly voluntary) from front-line combat roles; teaching self-defense and assertiveness; support of mothers and babies.
Thank you, Helen. Unsurprisingly, I agree with you. At its best, feminism is simply a form of humanism, with "humanism" here meaning a belief in the fundamental ethical equality of all human beings at birth and in the individual as the primary locus of autonomy and dignity. The same is true of "anti-racism." These words and their associated movements were necessary because many self-declared "humanists" effectively excluded women and ethnic minorities from full membership in the human species.
Human nature is expansive. It contains multitudes. There are differences between men and women on the whole, some of them quite important. But there are also undeniable commonalities among human beings that allow for understanding, recognition, and goodwill across sexes, cultures, races/ethnicities, etc. At its best, feminism recognizes as much. And thank you for extending me a bit of this recognition and goodwill.
But you don't actually treat people equally in practice though. Easy example: in the west, both sexes have equal opportunity to get completely drunk and have sex, yet if two people of different sexes do that one will be deemed as having raped the other, even if they were both just as impaired in terms of their decision making capacity. If however the people are not of different sexes the act will not be deemed rape. This is clearly not treating either the sexes or straight and gay people equally. What you are in fact telling people is: you have the same opportunity/freedom to do something, but if you avail yourself of that freedom we will treat you differently based on sex and sexual orientation
No, I’m not telling them that at all. That is the type of feminism that I expressly decried in the final section of my original note, the one to which this article is responding. The type of feminism you describe is very real, but I do not support it. I condemn it. In fact, I explicitly condemned it. I was very clear about this. Please do not put words in my mouth.
I meant "you" as in your society - you westerners - not you individually, I guess I should have made that clear. There is a big divide between what liberal societies and pundits preach in the abstract and what people living in your countries experience, that was my point. The version of an ideology you support might be the nominal (and legitimately worthy) goal, but if the one you decry is what people actually encounter in the wild, well, that has consequences. What something might be like at it's best ends up mattering little to people who only get to see it at it's worst. Thanks for replying anyway.
That's fair. The point that I was making is that language should be used in such a way as to distinguish the best in this matter from the worst. I am trying to reclaim "feminism," which historically is a very respectable term, from its more extreme proponents, of which there are sadly many. And I think Helen was making a similar point. If we do not do this, we run the risk of conflating liberal, humanistic feminism with critical theoretical feminism. And this will lead to an increase in both misandry and misogyny.
Well done Helen, as usual. Must be all the properly made tea - good for cognition. 😁
Spot on. The principle of equal protection before the law applies to everyone, and avoids singling out any identity group for elevated treatment.
Helen, i'm a fan, but I must say this post rubs me the wrong way.
Your take on liberal feminism seems premised on feminists' theoretical description of themselves rather than on an empirical assessment of what liberal feminism manifestly is. You write "in principle, it’s not fundamentally about women at all."
But then you write this:
"It is a recognition that women are individuals and people, and as such should have equal social and moral status and the same opportunities and freedoms as men."
I notice your language shift. You write first that liberal feminism is not about women at all fundamentally, but about both sexes. Yet you describe liberal feminism as concerned with women--not both sexes, but women--enjoying the benefits of equality. I think this tension in language tracks the tension between what liberal feminism theoretically is and what it manifestsly is.
Where are the liberal feminists clamoring to have women subjected to the selective service on the same terms as men? Where are the liberal feminists demanding that women receive the same heightened criminal sentences for crimes as men, including the death penalty? Where are the liberal feminists recognizing that a sexual double standard seems to apply in the university sexual misconduct context? Yes, liberal feminists sometimes address these issues, but usually only in a token way, as if they're doing the bare minimum in order to qualify as technically caring about men too.
You write:
"Nevertheless, in principle, [the liberal feminist] stance also protects men and should the need to defend them against such discrimination arise, explicitly advocates that. Men, therefore, can appreciate this principle and the framing of it to apply to both sexes."
"In principle," sure. And, in principle, "white pride" it's simply about pride in being white. It is not enough to tell me to celebrate liberal feminism because of the principles it abstractly claims to espouse. The proof is in the pudding and the pudding tastes like like less than genuine equality. Liberal feminism is relatively friendly to men compared to radical feminism, sure. i'm not saying that liberal feminists hate men. I am saying that they don't give two French farts about men, and therefore they don't deserve my admiration. Liberal feminism is and has always been gynocentric in practice. So why should I believe it's really something else? Because wikipedia says that they are about equality for both sexes?
In system theory there is a principle of progress where the course corrections early on eventually help achieve the purpose of the system, but then there is the inevitable corruption that occurs from human nature to constantly want more.
The design of Western democracy and the freedom to agitate for cause was always supposed to work this way:
People take time from their normal productive endeavors, including the crushing demands for managing a family and providing safety, security and sustenance, to agitate for a cause. Then after the war or the vote, people go back to their normal productive endeavors.
In this way, the "movement" if you will is always a temporary project that seeks to achieve some outcome and then ends.
Feminism has become an industry, and it has been corrupted as per the Shirky Principle. It in fact achieved all and more based on its initial outcome targets. It then should have gone away. But the feminists had attached themselves to the movement as a perpetual power, status and money-making enterprise. And feminized men attached themselves to the feminists for the same.
The movement went over the apogee of positive returns and has been on the downward slope for the last several decades. The 3rd and 4th wave feminists agenda is no longer about female choice and female equality. It is about pushing ideas that are the death of Western democratic capitalist liberal society to be replaced with a collectivist design that these feminists think will acquire them more power, status and money.
Feminism is frankly the current primary enemy of Western civilization. It is the new fascist movement and WWIII is upon us. Feminist females have become the conduit of destruction... the Pandora's Box fable come to life.
That's just feminism in an institutional sense. Any and all institutions end up moving in this direction. (But wow, an institution besides religion is being attacked!)
In the meantime it can't go away, because the biological differences between the sexes makes reversion to power inequality eternally tempting in human societies.
Keeping the main focus on the individual always much appreciated.
As I believe you have mentioned, anti-woke efforts are sometimes going too far these days. I am particularly sensitive to the generalizations about men and women I am hearing more and more often lately in liberal quarters. (Even "psychological differences" is going too far for me.) (Add particulars, and "generally" and I'm usually OK.)
I've heard that research shows some general differences between men and women's brains, which I am not knowledgeable enough to critique. Is it going too far into a 'post-modernist' mentality to say that my experience has shown me a lot of harm done to individuals who do not conform to some model of one sex or the other? To be a girl child who is considered odd for liking math. To be a boy child disapproved of for not being athletic.
Most of my life I have looked forward to a world which allows individuals to be their individual selves but with the left seeming to follow the right into lauding generalities over individuation, I sometimes wonder if we are fated to go in the other direction.
Liberalism is an excellent word at its root (liber = free), though over time it’s largely been co-opted to mean freedom PLUS a varying set of things that should be forced upon others in the service of personally compelling good intentions. Voluntaryism is a useful word in place of what liberalism once meant. Regardless of which meaning you tend towards, thanks for the thoughtful article (and the pointer to MJN Williams).
TLDR. Sorry Helen, but, offhand, feminism is something of a joke, a clownshow, all cohorts and sects -- over 20 at last count -- riding madly off in all directions -- as the English-Canadian humorist Stephen Leacock put it some 100 years ago.
You should have read the article because it criticizes radical feminism and other ultra-identitarian ideologies while arguing liberal feminism is a logical sub-focus of liberal activism as it reinforces individualism and moral universalism.
So I should try adjudicating between the 38,000 sects of Christianity as to which one is the genuine, real-meal deal? 🙄
She isn't arguing one is the true sect over the others. She is arguing for a feminism rooted in individualism and equal rights over illiberal indentitarian sects. She criticized the 19 illiberal sects of feminism in her article.
LoL. You say po-ta-toe, I say po-tat-oe. Pots & kettles methinks.
Reminds me of a classic case with a convocation of all of the religions in the world where the Dalai Lama had some choice criticisms of the lot.
Feminism consists of different groups of people. Pluckrose explains exactly which group she supports here, and it is a very coherent and principled stance. Perhaps you can explain how universal rights and individual freedom are "a joke, a clownshow"?
So she is championing one sect of over 20. Whole bunch of very questionable premises probably common to many of them, probably her own sect included, that weighs against them all. Failed ideology from square one. Cases in point being Koertge & Patai's Professing Feminism:
https://web.archive.org/web/20090807234859/http://www.feministcritics.org/blog/2009/07/27/professing-feminism-noh/
And Koertge's own:
The Feminist Critique [Repudiation] of Logic
https://philpapers.org/rec/KOETFC
Patai and Koertge are classical liberal feminists that criticized radical, indentitarian feminism in their works. Helen's argument here is also the same.
You didn’t even read it 🙄
Of course not. Why would you read the arguments in favour of one of the 38,000 Christian sects over any other one? Same difference -- various untenable articles of faith through the lot of them.
You might read those links of mine about the general criticisms of ALL of feminism -- bit of a joke from square one.
These are great points and I am definitely in general agreement! I think there is some need for recognition that some situations around reproduction may need a different legal framework than simple equality which is one thing that makes intermediate scrutiny jurisprudence (in the US context) pretty interesting. Setting aside Roe/abortion for the moment, first came Griswold on the pill. Do women have an articulable right to enjoy sex (which, contrary to some things I have heard on podcasts lately, we actually do?!) and still maintain control of their definitions about conceiving children? It’s a messy and vulnerable like of case law and one reason for feminism as a separate category (some other top of mind issues include the more clear cut cases of hostile work environment and sexual assault thought of course these can be articulated in a sex neutral way- but the fact intensive analysis may still need to take the sex identity of involved parties into account especially in working class settings.
I went on a side tangent after reading Duke law professor Doriane Coleman’s excellent book ‘On Sex and Gender’ a couple years back to refresh my memory on some of it and picked up a book on the 70s Ginsburg line of cases; recently purchased some Martha Nussbaum books on these topics. But those are some initial thoughts without having undertaken a deep review.
First: Helen, I have longed admired your fearless rationality and brilliant writing. While this essay is thoughtful, I disagree with it.
If legitimate feminism is liberalism—yet most feminists do not endorse the principles of liberalism—and feminism, as the data demonstrates, has achieved its original goals of equality before the law and of opportunity, I suggest we abandon the term. We can acknowledge its historic achievement, yet reject its modern corruption.
This is why I don’t call myself a feminist even though I suppprt the equal rights of women. I was asked to contribute a chapter to a book on feminisms and they cast me as a liberal post-feminist which sounds right to me.
I like it. I’m stealing it. 🌼
But you don't actually treat people equally in practice though. Easy example: in the west, both sexes have equal opportunity to get completely drunk and have sex, yet if two people of different sexes do that one will be deemed as having raped the other, even if they were both just as impaired in terms of their decision making capacity. If however the people are not of different sexes the act will not be deemed rape. This is clearly not treating either the sexes or straight and gay people equally. What you are in fact telling people is: you have the same opportunity/freedom to do something, but if you avail yourself of that freedom we will treat you differently based on sex and sexual orientation
Yes, I don’t think anybody is arguing we already do treat people equally. Rather the argument is that the liberal individualist and universalist position hold that we should and failures to do so are what they oppose. If we were already treating people as individuals with the same rights and responsibilities, there’d be nothing to address here.
Thank you for the reply! I agree with having the same rights and responsibilities, I think they are a package deal and a lot of current year problems come from people wanting rights but not responsibilities, and full range of choices but not the full range of outcomes that may result from those choices. I think the equal responsibility part isn't sufficiently stressed at all in liberal discourse. Maybe because it would be less popular as an ideology if it did so?
Thank you for your response. I support women’s rights (beyond what has already been achieved) if we mean biological women deserve special accommodations because of distinct physical and psychological characteristics: excluding biological men from women’s sports, private spaces, and shelters; providing security for women in vulnerable places (e.g. dark parking lots); exclusion (possibly voluntary) from front-line combat roles; teaching self-defense and assertiveness; support of mothers and babies.
Lovely! I was particularly struck by the triggering of the tribal brain, which so quickly responses, so often rather unproductively.