Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Stephen Bero's avatar

A monumental piece, Helen! I've been reading you for well nigh ten years, and this article and this article can serve as both an introduction to and summary of your work to date. (Not that I want you to stop here. Please keep writing!)

Since the ascendancy of Trump, I've been examining the idea of "consent of the governed, for here in the USA the vast majority of us governed, comprising those who voted for Trump and those who didn't vote at all, consented to being governed by a strongman cum plutocrats. Those of us in the liberal minority did not consent to this government. In this way, it appears democracy has deconstructed itself. The challenge for us liberals in the USA is not just promoting liberalism but first restoring democracy, this time with robust safeguards against authoritarianism.

Raymond Jensen's avatar

Whenever such a claim is made I have become accustomed to assuming the application of a highly inaccurate, proprietary definition of the -ism in question. Postliberal thinkers have made a habit of obfuscating their equivocation as they frivolously dance between various left of centre phenomenons. Hardly ever so they actually strike the actual content of liberalism. Perhaps they achieve high accuracy when they criticise open borders in europe, which at least has a economically liberal motivation under the four freedoms. But most of the time they conflate particularist identitarianism with liberalism itself, which is ironic since its main appeal is universality

18 more comments...

Ready for more?